Category: BOT757
| Athlete | High School | Sport | College | Class |
| Anderson Miller | First Colonial High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2012 |
| Avery Hall | Atlantic Shores | Football | Christopher Newport | 2011 |
| Avery Thompson | Grassfield High School | Football | University of Maryland | 2012 |
| Brandte McIntyre | Bishop Sullivan | Football | Alderson-Broaddus | 2012 |
| Brian Morgan | Princess Anne High School | Football | Christopher Newport | 2012 |
| Caleb Taylor | Phoebus High School | Football | University of Virginia | 2011 |
| Chaz Lowery | Ocean Lakes High School | Football | East Carolina University | 2011 |
| Conley Smith | Hickory High School | Football | Norfolk State | 2012 |
| Connor Mewbourne | First Colonial High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2011 |
| Corey Barnes | Nansemond River High School | Football | Delaware State | 2012 |
| DeShaun Summers | Phoebus High School | Football | Morgan State | 2012 |
| Hayden Crockett | York High School | Football | Alderson-Broaddus | 2012 |
| Jahmil Haley | Churchland High School | Football | Hampton University | 2012 |
| JC Coleman | Oscar Smith High School | Football | Virginia Tech | 2012 |
| Jerran Downing | Booker T. Washington | Football | Alderson-Broaddus | 2012 |
| Jocorey Robins | Norfolk Christian | Football | Concord | 2012 |
| Joe Nelson | York High School | Football | Virginia Military Institute (VMI) | 2012 |
| Jordan Broadnax | Landstown High School | Football | Umass | 2011 |
| Jordan Veal | Western Branch High School | Football | Virginia Military Institute (VMI) | 2012 |
| Josh Mann | Ocean Lakes High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2011 |
| Justin Lyles | Phoebus High School | Football | Concord | 2012 |
| Justin Williamson | Phoebus High School | Football | University of Richmond | 2011 |
| Kwontie Moore | Norfolk Christian | Football | University of Virginia | 2012 |
| Logan Bauder | York High School | Football | Alderson-Broaddus | 2012 |
| Lovante Battle | Phoebus High School | Football | University of Virginia | 2009 |
| Michael Garrett | Grassfield High School | Football | William & Mary | 2012 |
| Mylon Blueford | Oscar Smith High School | Football | University of Richmond | 2011 |
| Nicholas Kepa | Lafayette High School | Football | Christopher Newport | 2012 |
| Rashawn Proctor | Bethel High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2012 |
| Rod Holder | Indian River High School | Football | Coastal Carolina | 2012 |
| Ross Burbank | Cox High School | Football | University of Virginia | 2011 |
| Sequan Gooding | Oscar Smith High School | Football | Hampton University | 2012 |
| Steven Mason | Bethel High School | Football | St. Augustine's | 2012 |
| Ta'Quaon | Indian River High School | Football | Morgan State | 2012 |
| Tevin McGoughan | Phoebus High School | Football | Chowan University | 2011 |
| Troy Butler | Hickory High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2012 |
| Tyree Lee | Phoebus High School | Football | Old Dominion University | 2011 |
| Wil Wahee | Norfolk Christian | Football | University of Virginia | 2012 |
| Will Smith | Christ Church | Football | Wake Forest | 2012 |
| William Waters-Shorter | Grassfield High School | Football | Norfolk State | 2011 |
| Willie Ponder | Western Branch High School | Football | Towson University | 2012 |
| Brandon Doggett | Western Branch High School | Baseball | Lynchburg College | 2011 |
| Brian Lee | Cape Henry Collegiate | Baseball | William & Mary | 2012 |
| Casey Bryant | Ocean Lakes High School | Baseball | College of the Albemarle | 2011 |
| Jack Wyncoop | Cape Henry Collegiate | Baseball | University of South Carolina | 2012 |
| Josh Mason | Bishop Sullivan | Baseball | William & Mary | 2011 |
| Leland Clemmons | Indian River High School | Baseball | UNC-Charlotte | 2011 |
| Michael Donovan | Western Branch High School | Baseball | Virginia Military Institute (VMI) | 2011 |
| Sean Poppen | Cape Henry Collegiate | Baseball | Harvard | 2012 |
| Shane Johnsonbaugh | Western Branch High School | Baseball | Radford University | 2011 |
| Ashton Moore | Nansemond River High School | Basketball | The Citadel | 2011 |
| Josh Fortune | Kecoughtan High School | Basketball | Providence | 2012 |
| Trey Freeman | Kellam High School | Basketball | Campbell University | 2011 |